Grid Scale

Idaho’s largest battery storage project is financed. Will a NIMBY fight follow?

,
Idaho’s largest battery storage project is financed. Will a NIMBY fight follow?
A utility-scale lithium ion battery energy storage system (BESS) installation at Fort Carson in Colorado. Courtesy: Dennis Schroeder / NREL)

A clean energy developer has secured $323 million to finance a battery storage project in Idaho that would become the state’s largest once completed. But reaching that milestone could prove challenging given Idaho’s track record for opposing clean energy projects.

Aypa Power intends to develop, own, and operate a 150 MW/600 MWh battery storage facility in Kuna, Idaho just outside the capital of Boise. Aypa’s secured financing package includes a $233 million green loan, including a construction and term loan, a tax equity bridge loan, and a letter of credit facility. Additionally, the project secured $90 million in tax equity, bringing the total financing to $323 million. The company secured a 20-year agreement with Idaho Power last year and hopes to bring it online in 2025.

Renewable Energy World asked Aypa Power to see if the Idaho battery storage project requires any additional state or local approval and is awaiting a response. It’s a natural question for any clean energy project proposed in Idaho given a recent trend of local opposition.

Kuna residents recently came out in force against the 2,385-acre Powers Butte Energy Center solar project developed by Savion, Idaho News 6 reports. The proposed solar farm would be located in a rural farming area, much to the annoyance of the opposition, who say the farm would be a blight on the surrounding area.

Kuna residents attended the second public hearing on the Powers Butte Energy Center project, but Ada County Commissioners did not make a decision on the project’s future. By the end of the month, the Ada County Commission moved to halt on the project, BoiseDev reports, citing public opposition and their own feelings in their decision. Commissioners said the project would come with environmental concerns and unfavorable views.

Ryan Davidson, an Ada County Commissioner, called the decision “tough” and said the board he serves on is “not anti-solar.” He said the commission previously approved a Savion solar project that was developed “out in the desert,” instead of near residents.

A visual simulation of how Lava Ridge Wind would look with the 740-foot turbines in the original project proposal (courtesy: U.S. Department of the Interior, BLM)

It’s not just solar that faces an uphill battle in Idaho: a controversial wind project is facing another obstacle after Sen. Jim Risch introduced legislation to delay the 1,000 MW Lava Ridge Wind project, which is located on federal land near the Minidoka National Historic Site. The project’s opponents claim that the wind farm will “visually compromise” the historic site honoring more than 13,000 Japanese-Americans who were incarcerated during World War II.

Opposition to the Lava Ridge Wind project led the Bureau of Land Management to suggest nearly halving the size of the project from 400 turbines to 241 as part of the “preferred alternative” plan. Idaho’s state legislature unanimously passed a resolution in March 2023 expressing opposition to the Lava Ridge Wind Energy Project.

Based on local reporting, Idaho residents haven’t appeared to have objected to any battery storage project, though Aypa’s would be the state’s first utility-scale facility.

Idaho Power, the investor-owned utility providing electricity to most of the state, sees energy storage serving a key role in the future. Last year, the utility laid out a plan to acquire 101 MW of energy storage to address potential capacity shortfalls driven by limited third-party transmission capacity, load growth, and declining peak performance from several resources, NewsData reports. Some of that load growth will come from a Meta data center that’s expected to be completed in 2025.

Duke Energy Sustainable Solutions developed and owns the 120 MW Jackpot Solar project in Twin Falls County, Idaho. At the time that the project was placed into commercial operation, it was Idaho largest single utility-scale solar project. (Courtesy: Duke Energy)

While opponents of wind and solar — referred to unaffectionately as “NIMBYs,” an acronym for Not in My Backyard — have successfully fought projects across the country, the majority of Americas don’t mind living near clean energy projects, according to polling data.

A Washington Post-University of Maryland poll found around 75% of Americans are comfortable living near solar projects. Wind projects faired slightly worse at 70%. The poll did not ask about energy storage projects.

Despite broad support for clean energy projects in the U.S., at least 15% of counties have “halted new utility-scale wind, solar, or both,” according to a USA Today report, by implementing “outright bans, moratoriums, construction impediments, and other conditions.”